Main

Subscribe to This Category


Thoughts on Recent Reads

Here is another sampling of books I recently read and what I thought of them:

Straight Up by Lisa SampsonStraight Up
This story switches back and forth between narrators who are cousins, one of whom married a guy many years her senior who has since died and is trying to cope with life without him. The other cousin has great musical talent but she is dealing with a husband who went off to join a monastary and lots of childhood trauma. She is squandering her life with drinking and her other relatives try to help her but she may be beyond help.
This is definitely a thinking book, one that sucks you in and makes you examine the characters. It was good but not a "light read" so I would say that you have to be in the mood for a book that requires more thinking and reflection to pick this one up.

In High Places by Tom Morrisey

Continue reading "Thoughts on Recent Reads" »

It's All In a Cover

Cover picture from www.trashionista.comIt's amazing how much the cover of a book can affect your perceptions of it.  I'm fascinated by how book covers are designed and chosen.  Take the case of the US release of Liza Palmer's Seeing Me Naked.  Apparently, the picture to the left is what the US cover was originally going to look like, but the idea was nixed by the publisher. 

I personally don't see anything wrong with this cover, in fact I think it's rather eye-catching and would make me want to examine the book further to see what it was about.  Here is the US cover US cover picture from Amazon.comthe publisher settled on (to the right).

It's not bad, but I think I like the first one better. I like them both better than the UK cover thoughUK cover courtesy of www.trashionista.com (see below).

The line drawing style doesn't seem as appealing and to me it the illustration says that this is a cheeky romance novel, while the other covers seem to say it's more of a sophisticated book.

And isn't it interesting how as authors become better known their books are often re-released with different covers?  Check out these examples:

Continue reading "It's All In a Cover" »

52 Questions #52!!!!!!!! What was your favorite read of 2007?

Wow, a whole year has come and gone and it is finally time for the last question of this column.  Thanks to everyone who posted comments to my posts this past year, I enjoyed them all.  Here is the final question of this column and here's wishing everyone a very happy 2008!
One of my favorite reads of 2007For this week's question I'd like you to take a look back at the year that was and share: What were your favorite reads of 2007?  It could be a book published last year, or an older book that you discovered for the first time.  If you can't narrow it down to just one, tell us the top picks from your reading list.  Then we will all have a list of great reads to choose from as we start 2008!

As for myself, the top five books that I enjoyed are almost all older titles, classics even.  They include a couple of classic adventure stories that I enjoyed listening too as audiobooks: The Count of Monte Cristo by Alexandre Dumas (which took me all year to finish, and which I got as an audiobook download from Overdrive), and King Solomon's Mine by H. Rider Haggard (which I downloaded from TSCPL's Netlibrary service).  I also enjoyed The Illuminator by Brenda Rickman Vantrease,One of my favorite reads of 2007 for the way it portrayed ordinary people caught up in the drama of a turbulent historical time.  And I was impressed by a couple of non-fiction books: Ishmael Beah's A Long Way Gone: Memoirs of a Boy Soldier was hard to listen to at times, but a powerful story that informed me of the realities of life on the other side of the globe.  And I was inspired by Joanna Weaver's Having a Mary Heart in a Martha World--a devotional book that used the Biblical stories of Mary and Martha to reinforce the importance of slowing down and letting God speak to us.  This is one I hope to read again in 2008, as it has many lessons I didn't quite catch the first time.

52 Questions #51: What books are a part of your holiday traditions?

There are so many heartwarming holiday stories and poems that I hope you makeTwas the Night Before Christmas time each holiday season to enjoy at least one of them.  What books, short stories, poems, or audiobooks are a part of your holiday traditions?  Do you read Truman Capote's A Christmas Memory aloud at your holiday get togethers?  Do you listen to Jim Dale reaing A Christmas Carol by Charles Dickens as you drive around looking at the holiday displays?  Does reading Twas the Night Before Christmas with your kids on Christmas Eve put you in the holiday spirit?  Please share in the comments below.

As for myself, I have several Christmas stories that I like to The Littlest Angelvisit each year and that put me in the holiday mood.  One that you should never read without having a box of kleenex handy is A Littlest Angel by Charles Tazwell.  I still have my copy from childhood at home, and it is a good book to bring out and read at this time of the year--although it never fails to make me cry.  A more uplifting book that I would recommend is to listen a reading of A Child's Christmas in Wales by Dylan Thomas.   His descriptions of snowball fights, tormenting cats, and such never fail to bring a chuckle to my lips.

Happy holidays everyone, and next week we will have our final 52 Questions post of the year!

52 Questions #50: What are your Reading Deal-Breakers?

When the Emperor Was Divine by Julie OtsukaHave you ever been reading a book and then just had to stop because it contained something you just don't like to read about?  If a dog dies, or a child is hurt, or someone is raped, or a creepy serial killer dismembers someone is it enough to make you stop reading?  What kinds of things will make you put down and book and not be able to finish it?

I knowHelter Skelter--One of the True Crime books I tried to read for a lot of people, the scene in When the Emperor Was Divine where the dog is killed bothered them so much they had trouble finishing the book.  I didn't like that scene either, but I managed to get through it and read the rest of the book.  I can usually get past creepy/sad scenes if there aren't too many of them.  But the one genre I have the most problem with is true crime.  I can read all kinds of fiction about murderers and such, but I can't read too much true crime without getting freaked out.  Knowing it is true starts to make me paranoid and keeps me up at night.

52 Questions #49: What Place from a Book Would You Most Want to Go?

As I was reviewing the questions I've written over the course of this yearThis is one of the books set in the European Middle Ages I read (and trying to remember what I had written about) I observed that I haven't asked any questions related to the many wonderful settings we can find in books.  Some authors do such a wonderful job of describing a place or even creating a whole new world that it makes you just want to go there.  Where in a book would you like to go?  Would you like to go somewhere familiar or exotic?  In a book you can not only travel to places around the globe, but also to different times, different planets, alternate universes, and fantasy worlds. 

Hmmmm, I can think of many places from books that I would love to visit--and several that I would not want to go to.  I've recently read some books set in Prince Caspian--the movie based on this book from the Narnia series is coming out next summer!Europe during the Middle Ages which I really liked, but while I have enjoyed learning about that time period I'm not sure I'd want to go for an extended visit.  It'd be hard to live without modern day conviences.  I do think I'd like hanging out with Robin Hood and his friends in the forest of England, especially after reading about their adventures in Hood by Stephen Lawhead.  I'd also be cool to visit the Shire or the Elven lands from the J.R.R. Tolkien Lord of the Rings series.  I'd want to stay out of Mordor though.  And I would absolutely love to visit the land of Narnia from the Chronicles of Narnia series by C.S. Lewis.  At least we can always visit these places in our imaginations, and the best thing is, it won't cost us anything.

52 Questions #48: Do You Have a Special Reading Place?

This is where I like to readDo you have a special reading place?  Many of us will read just about anywhere, but is there a place you have that you gravitate towards when you are ready to settle in for a good long read?  Is it an especially comfortable couch? A chair? Or do you read in bed?  Do you have any accesories that you like to have with you when reading--a nice light, a snuggly throw, a hot beverage in a special mug?

As for myself, I do have a very comfortable chair in my office room at home that I like to curl up in and read.  I keep a very warm throw next to it in case it is a chilly evening, and sometimes I indulge in a cup of hot chocolate or tea while reading.  I mostly like that spot because it is quiet and cozy--it is also where I write in my journal every evening so there is also a pen and paper handy in case I want to write something down.  There is a radio/CD player in that room too so I can turn on some quiet background music if I wish (it has to be strictly instrumental if I'm reading, if it's music with words I find it too distracting).   I'm so glad I have a nice spot like this too read, I just wish I had more time to use it! 

52 Questions # 47: What books are on your Christmas wish list?

Wow, we are on question # 47 which means there is only ONE MONTH left until One of the books on my wish listChristmas.  It's time to start dreaming of all the wonderful presents you will hopefully receive this year, as well as to start purchasing gifts for all those on your shopping list.  So, to help each other out, let's share:  What book or book related items are on your Christmas wish list this year?  Who knows, maybe someone you know (or Santa) will see what you want and you'll find it under the tree on Christmas morning!
One of the books on my wish list
As for myself, I love cooking and would be delighted to receive a well written and beautifully illustrated cookbook Christmas morning.  One of my favorite cooking websites is allrecipes.com, so I would particularly like to get one of their cookbooks (that I don't already have).  I've also become fond of the Cook's Country magazine this past year, so it would be wonderful to get a subscription or to receive one One of the books from my wish listof their cookbooks.  Don't forget that audiobooks make good gifts too, I'd love to have the 2007 audiobook of the year,  The Bible Experience, around on CD to listen to again and again.   Or how about The Chronicles of Narnia CD box set, or The Lord of the Rings, or (I'm really dreaming here) the new Complete Conan Doyle Sherlock Holmes set from the BBC.  I could go on, but I think I'd better stop there.

52 Questions #46: Which fictional family would you like to eat Thanksgiving dinner with?

So next week we will be celebrating Thanksgiving, most of us by getting togetherI'd like to sit down for a feast with this family   Image courtesy of Wikipedia for a feast with our relatives.  That got me thinking of some of the memorable families from the world of literature and what it might be like to sit down for a meal with them.  Some I think would be very enjoyable (mabye even more enjoyable than with your real relatives), some not.  What do you think, which family from a book would you like to eat dinner with and why?  Or are there any you would not want to dine with and why not?

There are so many memorable families to choose from it's hard to pick just one.  Some would be nice to eat with for the loving and warm atmosphere you know would be there: The March family from Little Women, the Ingalls from the Little House books.  Some would provide a more stimulating and lively atmosphere: The Gilbreth family from Cheaper by the Dozen, The Weasley family from the Harry Potter series.  Some, like the Corleone family from the Godfather books, I think I would be scared to eat with unless I could be an invisible observer.  My final pick would be sit down with the Cratchit family from Dicken's A Christmas Carol to eat roast goose with sage and onion stuffing and Christmas pudding--provided by a reformed Mr. Scrooge.

52 Questions #45: Does the Author's Background Matter?

Oprah Winfrey has caused a bit of a stir recently for a decision she made Oprah's decision to remove this book from her website has caused controversyto remove The Education of Little Tree by Forrest Carter from a list of recommended books on her website.  The book, a children's tale about an orphaned boy raised by Cherokee grandparents, is controversial because the author was really Asa Earl Carter, an outspoken white supremacist who was a member of the Klu Klux Klan and a speechwriter for Alabama governor George Wallace.  According to the AP news story, Oprah said that including the book on the list was an "archival error" and that she no longer feels the same about the book after learning the truth about the author. 
So readers, what do you think?  Did Oprah make the right decision in removing the book from her list of recommended titles?  Or should the story be judged on it's own merits and our reaction to it be divorced from what we know about the author?

I haven't read the book so I can't comment on how well it was written or the way it portrays the Cherokee people.  I do know part of the controversy is that the author originally said it was a true story--and later it was found out to be a work of fiction-- which does seem pretty unexcusable.  What Oprah did was a personal decision about what she was going to endorse.  People certainly have the right to choose who and what they are going to support and not support.  As far as allowing what you know about an author's background to influence your opinion of their writing, that's a tougher question. All writing is a form of communication, and as such it's hard to not let what you know about the creator of that communication to influence how you think about their work.  Does knowing that Thomas Jefferson was a slaveholder influence the way you think about the Declaration of Independence?  It's intriguing to speculate about what the author was thinking about or what his or her motivations were when he or she chose to write about a particular topic.  Yet stories also seem to have a life of their own, and they may end up being interpreted and used in ways far beyond what the author imagined or intended.  So while the author's background can add insight into a story or help us understand why it it was initially written, in the long run I think the writing will stand or will not stand because of how true it comes across to the reader, not because of who or what the author was.

52 Questions #44: Do You Like to Read about Your Job?

In a recent article from the Topeka Capital Journal, federal prosecutor Prosecuting Attorney Jeffries likes to read mysteries like this in her spare timeJune Jeffries talks about how she likes to read murder mysteries in her spare time.  Her passion for seeing justice delivered thus spills over from her work day to her leisure time.
That got us wondering about whether our readers also like to read books related to their professions.  Do you like to read books about your job? Or do you like to escape from the workplace and enter an entirely different world when you read?

As for myself I do like to read novels featuring librarians as characters or that are set in libraries. One that I enjoyed recently was Monday Morning Faith by Lori Copeland, in which the main character is a librarian.  She was very stereotyped in that she liked order and calm and so the whole book was about her breaking out of her boring little world when she starts dating a guy who wants to be a missionary doctor to Papua New Guinea.  But it wasn't too far off the mark in terms of what she did on the job.  One of the fun things about reading a book related to your job is either spotting where the author got it right or where they got it wrong.  It can be annoying if the book gets details about the job wrong--thankfully this one didn't.  I like my job so I like reading books set in the same kind of wonderful world where I work.  How about you?

52 Questions #43: Can authors tell you too much about a character?

Rowling's Comments about Dumbledore have created a lot of controversySo a certain author caused a bit of a flap recently when she made a revealing comment about one of her characters that may or may not change how that character is perceived in her books.  This question isn't about that as about how much you like authors telling you these extra bits of information about their book after the fact.  Do you like learning all these extra bits of detail, or would you prefere the author just left well enough alone and left it up to the reader's imagination?
I can certainly understand enjoying the world and characters an author has created so much that you want to learn every possible detail about them.  It allows you to spend some more time in that world and can create more depth in the characters and your understanding of them.  But then it's also fun to imagine the characters in your own way and have your own mental image of what they and their world is like.  This is probably why so often movies based on books are disappointing--they just don't measure up to or shatter the mental image you have created on your own.  And I also think having a bit of ambiguity makes it more fun to discuss the books with other people.  How can you speculate and debate over details in the books if every little detail is spelled out by the author?  So once the book has been written and released I would say the author can keep these details to him or herself--unless he or she is going to write them into another book.

52 Questions #41: What Old Family Recipes Do You Want to Save?

The editors of Cook's Country thought it would be a good idea to help New Cookbook Collect Family Recipespeople preserve their family traditions by asking them to write down and submit old family recipes for a new coobook.  The result is America's Best Lost Recipes: 121 Kitchen-Tested Heirloom Recipes Too Good to Forget.  The recipes published were the best out of the more than 2800 submitted, according to this article from USA today.  The article also includes a few of the recipes and stories--the Hungarian Sweet Rolls sound scrumptious!

So to celebrate this new book coming out, let's ask the question: What old family recipes would you most want to save (or wish you had saved)?  You don't necessarily have to share the recipe with us (though that would be great it you did!).

As for myself, I sure wish I had my grandmother's recipe for the yummy apple pie and applesauce she used to make.  I suspect it wouldn't be the same though without the apples from the tree that used to grow in her yard though.  I still remember climbing up in that tree to pick the apples when I was little and helping her chop them up.  I remember lots of sugar and cinammon were involved in making her pies (the apples were really tart) but that's about it.  Sadly, my grandmother is not with us anymore.  I suggest you get your family recipes written down before it is too late!

52 Questions #40: Speedreading--Yay or Nay?

Speed Reading bookMany readers today feel pressured to not just read, but to read fast.   A recent BBC news article about the judging for the Man Booker Prize notes that the judges were faced with the daunting task of reading about 100 novels in 100 days.  Yikes! I've often read a novel in a day, but I doubt I could keep that pace up for 4 months.   But, book contest judge or not, in this day and age of information overload the BBC article suggest that we would all benefit from being able to read quicker.  Some have even turned reading into a competitive sport, using websites like LibraryThing to track their reading and compare it to others, or just try to beat their personal best from previous years.
What do you think, is speed reading good or bad?  Does it really matter how quickly you are able to read a book, or make a difference in how much you remember it later?  As readers do we lose something by reading too quickly?

As for myself, I have been blessed with an ability to read rather quickly which I often do.  I will also skim a book or skip parts of it on occasion, if I decide once I start reading it that I'm not interested in reading it deeply.  Some books are harder to read fast than others, and I think some are too good to speed through.  No matter how much you speed read, I think that you should always retain the ability to sit and savor a novel.  So speed read yes, but not all the time.  And for the record, according to my LibraryThing list I've read 91 books so far this year...can anyone beat that? 

What We're Reading

Ever wonder what library staffers are reading when they aren't working?  At a recent staff meeting we discussed books we had recently read and enjoyed.  Here is a list of what we discussed, since we have varied reading interests you're sure to find something you would enjoy too:
The Great Mortality
The Great Mortality : an intimate history of the Black Death, the most devastating plague of all time by John Kelly

The Last Good Kiss by James Crumley

Patriot Hearts: a novel of the founding mothers by Barbara Hambly

Mason Dixon Knitting by Kay Gardiner
Mason Dixon Knitting
Breaking Back: How I lost everything and won my life by James Blake

Ava Gardner: Love is Nothing by Lee Server

Pure Flavor: 125 fresh All-American recipes from the Pacific Northwest by Kurt Beecher Dammeier

Epic by Conor KostickFour Seasons in Rome

Bridge of Sighs by Richard Russo

The Abstinence Teacher by Tom Perrotta

The Brief Wonderous Life of Oscar Wao by Junot Diaz

A Long Way Gone: Memoirs of a boy soldier by Ishmael Beah

Four Seasons in Rome: On twins, insomnia, and the biggest funeral in the history of the world by Anthony Doerr

Embryo Culture: Making babies in the twenty-first century by Beth Kohl

52 Questions #39: What Do You Keep in the Car to Read...Just in Case?

In a recent article from the Oregonian, the author talks about how he has gotten into the habit of keeping some books in his car just in case he needs something to read.  This prompted him to do an informal poll with his reader friends--and he found out many of them had the same habit, keeping items ranging from dictionaries, atlases and phone directories to comic books, books of knitting patterns and a handbook on vipassana meditative practice.   The most common books he found to be carried around in cars, besides overdue library books, were Dr. SeusHow many of you have a Dr. Seuss book floating around in your car?s books. 
So readers, do you indulge in this habit of keeping a book or two in your car in case of a need-to-read emergency?  And if so what do you keep in your car to read?

As for myself, I do generally have some books floating around in my car.  I always keep a phone book in the car, which is extremely useful and has bailed me out several times when I need to know an address, phone number, or refer to a local map.  (BTW, the library has free copies of phone books that we are giving away, in case you want an extra for your car).  Besides that I think I have some old magazines stuck in one of the seat pockets, a couple of audiobooks, a couple of inspirational novels.   I like the Dr. Seuss idea, I think I will put one in my car, what could be better to cheer you up in a stressful situation.  Do any of you women carry books around in your purses?  I sometimes have a paperback in mine, and I always have a small Bible in there for reflection.  I guess I'm well prepared in case of a reading emergency!

52 Questions # 38: What Five Books Should Everyone Read at least Once?

This is in response to a list that's been around for a while, but which I just learnedLolita, One of the books Oprah says you should read about.  On Oprah's website you can find this article about the Five Books Everyone Should Read At Least Once.  Their picks are Lolita by Vladimir Nabokov, Four Quartets by TS Eliot, The Wisdom of the Desert: Sayings from the Desert Fathers of the Fourth Century translated by Thomas Merton, Waiting for Godot by Samuel Beckett and Things Fall Apart by Chinua Achebe.
First of all, I'm not entirely sure that lists like this are such a good idea.   Who have given the author of this article and Oprah the authority to say that these are books everyone should have read?  Of course, I might be a bit put off because I haven't personally read any of these books. 
But for the sake of this blog post, which is supposed to ask you a question, I will ask: What do you think of this list?  Do you like lists like this or do they make you I think you should read this insteadmad?  And of course, if you were to put together a list of 5 books everyone should read, what would you include?
As for myself, if I put together such a list I think it would include books that I consider important to read because they have become a part of our western culture and so knowing them helps you understand the frequent allusions that are made to them.  So I would include books like Don Quixote by Cervantes, Moby Dick by Herman Melville, War and Peace by Leo Tolstoy, Hamlet by William Shakespeare, and The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn by Mark Twain.  I'm not saying that those are the final five I would pick, but those are the kind of books I would choose.

52 Questions #37: In 2017 Libraries Will Be....

Share your vision of the future!  That is the focus of a campaign being run by the National Library of New Zealand.  They are asking their users to share with them what they think libraries will be like by the year 2017--just 10 years from now.  You can see the responses the have gotten here.  Check it out and then let us know your ideas for what the future of libraries should be in the comments below.



Created with Admarket's flickrSLiDR.

52 Questions #36: Do Looks Matter in an Author?

A recent article by the Boston Phoenix examined a trend of the modern publishing Pessl's bookworld: Authors that are young, hip, and good looking seem to be more likely to become published and to be marketed into literary stars.  To quote from the article: "Books no longer need to be serious in order to be published; there are fewer and fewer venues available for reviews ... Perhaps as a response to all of this, publishers have begun to count on their authors to do double-duty — to act as sex symbols as well."  Some authors that the article mentions as belonging to the new "postmodern canon of Hot Young Authors" include Marisha Pessl, Jonathan Safran Foer, Nell Freudenburger and Benjamin Kunkel.  The article says that these authors have gotten a lot of attention--and a lot of scrutiny--Freudenburguer's bookbecause "their youth and appearance have given them an advantage that a less striking yet more gifted writer would never achieve"
Is this a symptom of our culture that worships a person's surface appearance while ignoring his or her true literary talents?  Does it appall you to think that one author may be picked for publication over another because of his or her sex appeal?  Or is it unfair to pick on these authors just because they happen to be blessed with good looks?  Do looks matter in an author?--tell us what you think in the comments below.
As for myself, I would say in no way should the way a person looks affect whether they should be published.  As to whether it matters to me when I'm picking out something to read...I usually look at the author picture last, if at all, when picking out a book so it doesn't really make that much difference to me.  In fact, I tend not to care until I've actually read a bit of the book and gotten to know that person's writing.  Then I might wonder about what the author looks like based on what I've learned about them from their words.  And I think that might matter more to me if it is a non-fiction book rather than a novel, because for some reason knowing that person's thoughts on a particular topic or hearing their life experiences would make me more curious about what they look like than reading a fictional story that they made up.

52 Questions #35: What Book Do You Most Wish Was True?

Do You Wish This Was Real?Have you ever finished a really great novel and thought--"man, I wish that story was really true"?  Maybe you wish you could meet that extraordinary character in person, or experience that amazing fantasy world, or team up with the detective and solve the mystery.  If you had to choose one book that you could really bring to life, what would you choose?  Would you want to travel through the world of Middle Earth as depicted in the Lord of the Rings?  Or meet Atticus Finch from To Kill a Mockingbird?  What fictional book or character do you most wish was true?  Tell us in the comments below.
As for myself, I think I would have to vote for The Adventures of Sherlock Holmes by Sir Arthur Conan Doyle.  Of course I'd have to transport myselfI wish he was real back to Victorian London to meet them, but what a thrill if Sherlock Holmes and Dr. Watson were real!  I'd love to spend an evening with them in Baker street hearing about their adventures in person, or maybe even a new client would suddenly pop in and we'd be off on another adventure--one I haven't read about! 

52 Questions #34: Do you want your favorite series to die with the author?

Jason Bourne's adventures continued by LustbladerOnce an author has created a trademark style, vivid fantasy world, or enduring character, you can see why some fans would not want that creation to end with the author's death.  For example, the estate of Ian Fleming recently commissioned Sebastian Faulks to write a new Bond adventure--this after already having author Raymond Benson write several Bond adventures.  Bond is of course not the only series character to live on after his creator's death, other examples include Robert Ludlum's Bourne novels, which have been continued by Eric Van Lustblader, or the new Godfather novel by Mike Winegardner, or the novels by Brian Herbert and Kevin J. Anderson that revisit the world of Dune
As a reader, what do you think of a different author continuing a book series after the author is dead?  Does the very idea make you cringe, or do you rejoice that your favorite characters or setting won't be lost forever?
As for myself, I tend to stay clear of these type of continuations (though I remember reading every OZ book I could get a hold of when I was young, whether it  was written by L. Frank Baum or not).  Most often, no other author can duplicate the characteristics of the original well enough, though sometimes they can do a masterful adaptation using their own style.  If I do read enough good press and reviews I might give it a try, but otherwise I'd move on to something else.

52 Questions #33: Hardbacks vs. Paperbacks

Pile o' paperbacks--my favoriteI'm sure most every reader has a preference/opinion on this topic: Do you prefer hardback or paperback books?  Does it matter if you are buying a book for yourself or as a gift for someone else?  Or what type of book that it is or where you are going to be reading it?

As for myself, I prefer paperbacks most of the timeHardbacks aren't as good, in my opinion.  I like that they are lighter and easier to carry when reading while walking.  Or if you are traveling they are so much easier to pack (who else packs their suitcase by what books will fit in it the easiest?).  I might make an exception for something like a cookbook or if I need a handy doorstop, but otherwise I think paperbacks are far easier to manage.

52 Questions #32: Should listening to the audio version count as reading a book?

A recent article published in an Indian newspaper, using Audio vs Print, which is better?content from the New York Times, chronicles the debate in some book clubs and reading circles between audiobook users and traditional readers.  Apparently, some audiobooks listeners are looked down on when they admit that they have listened to the book instead of reading it traditionally, especially if they are in a book discussion group. 
What!  I thought this debate was long dead, considering how long audiobooks have been around their increasing popularity.   I wonder if the audio reader would get even more of a cold shoulder for admitting they downloaded the book to their computer and listened to in on their MP3 player?
So what do our readers think, do you think listening to a book is the same as reading it?  If you are to read the book for a discussion group, are you more likely to think you have to read the print version, and not "cheat" by listening to it?

As for myself, let me start by saying if I was to read a book for discussion, it would take me LESS TIME to actually read it than to listen to it.  By listening to the audio version I would have spent more time with the book and maybe even spent more time thinking about its meaning than if I read the printed words.  I think you pick up on different things when you listen rather than read, so maybe some of what you would have experienced by seeing the words is lost, but other insights are gained by HEARING the words said aloud.   Let's celebrate the differences, not censure someone for choosing to experience the story in a different way.  One final thought on an advantage of listening versus reading: You'll know the correct way to pronounce some of the names and places in the book, how many of those that read the printed version can say that?

52 Questions #31: Should authors use famous dead people as characters?

Our fascination with the lives of celebrities often transcends death and reality, as novelists and moviemakers find plenty of fodder for their new releases in the past.Some people didn't like the way this novel portrayed Jacqueline Onassis  The upcoming movie Becoming Jane is just one example of a well known person's life being fictionalized for our entertainment.  Jacqueline Kennedy Onassis, Elvis Presley, and Jane Austen herself have often popped up as characters in novels--sometimes doing things they never would have done in real life, such as solving mysteries or saving the planet from swamp mutants.
What do you think about such novels, do you enjoy reading about famous dead people in novels, or do you find the way they bend the historical facts disturbing?  Is it OK if the person is long dead and not so OK if the person is more recently deceased and has family members or friends still living who may be offended?  Share I liked the portrayl of JFK in this novelyour thoughts with us in the comments below.
As for myself, I usually find such fictional portrayls to be very enjoyable.  For example I recall reading Homer Hickam's The Ambassador's Son, in which a young John F Kennedy appears as a character, and finding that it made the story more intesting to have this bit of history thrown in.  So for the most part I would say "yes" to such novels, though if I don't like the way the author portrayed the celebrity or thought it was done in poor taste I probably wouldn't read another one of his or her books.  After all, if there are family members or friends who don't like the way their loved one is portrayed, they can always write their own version of the story.

52 Questions #30: What Do You Think of Author Collaborations?

I got started thinking about this topic by some recent news about a planned Janet Evanovich & Stephen Cannell collaboration--that may not be coming out as Peretti and Dekker's House wasn't the best collaborationplanned later this year, according to an article posted at galleycat.  Scheduling problems have apparently caused the delay.
Aside from busy authors having a hard time getting together, do you think author collaborations are a good idea?  Are you more likely to read a book if it's done by not one of your favorite authors, but two of them working together?  Or do you avoid such books, figuring that they are marketing ploys and that the collaboration can't be nearly as good as the author's individual works?
As for myself, I've had both good and bad experiences with Peterson's and Miller's collaboration seemed to be well donecollaborations.  Some--like Ted Dekker and Frank Peretti's House--weren't nearly as good as the author's individual works.  Sometimes you can tell that the author's styles just don't mesh very well, and the result feels patched together.  That does make you wonder if they just did it so the publishers could put those two names on the same cover.  But I have really enjoyed other co-authored books, like the Tracie Peterson/Judith Miller Bells of Lowell and Lights of Lowell series.  But then these authors were collaborating for different reasons, and seem to have found a method and style that works well for them.  So my verdict would be, if it just seems like a marketing ploy, stay away, but if it's just two lesser known authors working together then give it a try.

52 Questions # 29: Do You Find Readers More Attractive?

Imagine this: You are a single person on the prowl.  You see him/her across aDoes the fact that she's reading make her more attractive? crowded room.  You think "Hmmm, that person looks interesting, maybe I'll go check him/her out".  As you approach, you notice that person is carrying something....A book!  What reaction does this provoke?  Do you feel elated that the person is a reader--or not?  Or will you be filled with a desire to see exactly what it is the other person is reading...and be either turned off or turned on by what it is?
A scenario like this was on the minds of the folks at Borders, who asked the internet survey group YouGov to do a survey on how reading habits influence the opinions of strangers.  According to this CultureVulture blog post, of the 2000 people surveyed, many of them said they would smile at someone, or even flirt with them, if they saw them holding a book.  But not just any book--apparently the survey respondent indicated that classics, biographies, and modern literary fiction were their biggest literary turn-ons.
So now I'd like to ask this question of our readers: Does seeing someone with a book make them seem more attractive to you?  What kind(s) of books would be either a turn-on or a turn-off?  And if anyone has any good stories about hooking up with someone because of a shared reading interest, do share!
As for myself, I would have to say that obviously having a shared interest is always a big selling point when you are checking someone out, so of course for us readers it's exciting to find out our potential love interest is also a reader.  I hope that people aren't too quick to come to conclusions based on someone holding a particular book though--as I can think of many reasons why a person might either be reading something they don't normally read or just be carrying the book around but not reading it.   So, <sigh>, I guess we're back to actually having to get to know the person before deciding that he or she is our dream date.

52 Questions #28: What Do You Think of Celebrities Turned Authors?

Junior by Macaulay Culkin Madonna's done it.  Jay Leno has too.  Julie Andrews Edward's been doing it for years. What have they done?  Cashed in on their fame to get a book published--and not a book about their lives, but a fictional book for children or adults.  Publishers seem to think that when readers see a name like John Lithgow or Jamie Lee Curtis or even Macaulay Culkin on the cover these books will become instant bestsellers.
So are they right?  When you seen the name of a celebrity on the cover of a novel, are you more inclined to pick it up and read it?  Or are you like the authors of this article, turnedJamie Lee Curtis' book off by the thought of a celebrity getting a profitable book deal while talented authors struggle to get published?  Tell us what you think of celebrity authors by leaving a comment below.
As for myself, I don't pay much attention to the doings of celebrities, so seeing a star studded name on the cover of a book wouldn't impress me much.  I'm more easily swayed by what friends, colleagues, or reviewers have said is good, or by what my own tastes lead me toward.  And when I'm looking for a good novel that has never been to a celebrity author.

52 Questions #27: Robert Heinlein's 100th birthday, What do you think?

 Today (7/7/07) marks the 100th anniversary of the birth of science fiction author Robert Heinlein--a fact which has not gone unnoticed by fans.  This weekend they will be gathering in Kansas City for the Robert A. Heinlein Centennial event.  It sounds like a lot of fun for science fiction fans, with a variety of guests including Sir Arthur C. Clarke (via video feed), Spider Robinson, James E. Gunn, and more. 
So for this weeks questions I'd like to ask: What do you think of Robert Heinlein?  Do you have a favorite book?  A favorite memory from his writing?  Or have you never read him but have always thought you should? 
As for myself, I have vivid memories of reading Heinlein's The Door Into Summer when I went on a sci fi reading binThis is my favorite Heinlein book--what's yours?ge a while ago.  I had heard he was an author I shouldn't miss, and I must say I wasn't disappointed.   The Door Into Summer, written in 1957, is interesting to read today because it contains Heinlein's unique vision of the future, as he thought it would develop at that time.  So we have a main character to is transported from 1970 to the year 2000 via the method of taking "the long sleep"--he is put into a state of suspended animation and revived 30 years later.  So it was interesting, if a little confusing at times, to see way Heinlein thought modern society would develop.  The best part was the way the wove the human element into the story though, as a reader I got wrapped up in the story of the main character and how he wanted to go back and fix what went wrong in his past.  I would say, if you haven't given Heinlein a read before, this is definitely and excellent time to discover him.

52 Questions # 26: Do You Judge a Book by It's Cover?

This is the cover of an older version of "Brave New World"--would YOU want to read it?The old saying says you "shouldn't judge a book by it's cover", but when browsing for a good read doesn't a nice looking cover stand out over a plain one?  Some publishers have even gone as far as to "repackage" the works of classic authors in modern looking jackets.  Recently Jane Austen's works were published with pastel covers of the "chick lit" variety, which reportedly was harshly criticized by Here is a more modern cover, is it more appealing?author Deborah Maggach, though Sophie Kinsella seemed to think it was OK. 
So what do you think, do you care what a book's cover looks like?  Should the old classics be "repackaged" with modern covers, or is it somehow demeaning to see a Dickens book look just like something published yesterday?
Personally I have enjoyed both books with snazzy looking covers and ones with covers as plain as could be.  But generally I don't choose my books by browsing the shelves--I usually am choosing from reviews and online book descriptions.  Some books that I listen too don't have covers at all--I download them directly to my computer!  So while I can understand while an attractive cover might matter to the book browser, it makes no difference to me.  Repackage all you want